“What was done in the dark”
After years of stonewalling Clarence Moses-EL’s innocence claim, Denver’s DA is trying to keep a confession in a 1987 rape case from coming to light.
“I really don’t know what to say to you,” began the letter, written in neat script on prison-issue loose leaf paper.
“But let’s start by bringing what was done in the dark into the light. I have a lot on my heart.”
The heavy-hearted writer, L.C. Jackson, was prosecuted by Denver District Attorney Mitch Morrissey’s cold case unit for the 1992 rapes at gunpoint of a mother and her 9-year-old daughter. Jackson has been serving 135 years in Colorado’s prison system since his 2007 conviction.
The letter’s recipient: Clarence Moses-EL, who’s doing his 28th year behind bars on a different case — a 1987 rape and brutal beating of a woman in Denver’s Five Points neighborhood. From the day of his arrest he has said he’s innocent.
“It’s my truth. It’s the truth. And, sooner or later, it will set me free,” Moses-EL, 59, told The Colorado Independent in a recent prison interview.
Though Moses-EL and Jackson lived in the same housing project in the 1980s, and though Jackson has cycled in and out of the same corrections system where Moses-EL has been housed since his 1989 rape conviction, they’ve said they’ve met only once – more than a quarter century ago at the Denver County Jail, and only in passing.
Each was well aware of the other.
Jackson knew Moses-EL was, at that time, awaiting trial for the rape and beating of Jackson’s neighbor and acquaintaince – a case for which Moses-EL was sentenced to 48 years.
For his part, Moses-EL knew that Jackson was the first man the victim in his case told police attacked her. In fact, she named him several times until, a day and a half later, she changed her story to say Moses-EL’s identity came to her in a dream. What she didn’t mention is that in the weeks leading up to her attack she had been fighting with Moses-EL’s wife and vowed to “get back” at her.
The victim’s dream was the only evidence linking Moses-EL to the attack for which Jackson was never questioned as a suspect. Yet it was enough, amazingly, for a jury to convict him.
“A dream,” Moses-EL told this reporter in a 2007 Denver Post interview. “I’m in here because of a dream.”
This afternoon, in Denver District Court. L.C. Jackson is scheduled to testify about what he says really happened that night 28 years ago.
Since sending his letter to Moses-EL in 2012, Jackson has admitted to having had rough sex with and beating up the victim in Moses-EL’s case at the exact time and the exact place of her attack. Confessing after all these years, he has told lawyers and investigators, is helping him come clean with his life. It’s a relief, he has said, finally to bring to light what was “done in the dark.”
But Denver District Attorney Mitch Morrissey has long tried to make sure that what was done in the dark stays shrouded in darkness.
Even though Morrissey has touted his office’s role in solving the cold case mother-daughter rapes for which it won convictions and life sentences against Jackson, he has asserted – falsely, several documents show – that the victim in Moses-EL’s case never named Jackson as her attacker.
Morrissey also has defended his office’s and Denver police’s involvement in destroying all the DNA evidence in Moses-EL’s case – truth-telling evidence that could have freed him more than two decades ago.
After Moses-EL won two court orders and raised $1,000 from fellow inmates to have a rape kit, bedding and the victim’s clothing genetically tested in 1993, police had packaged the items in a box they marked “DO NOT DESTROY.” Then, before the box could be sent to the lab, they threw it in a dumpster.
The lead Denver Police detective on the case said before his death that he had reservations about Moses-EL’s involvement.
What’s more, the details of Jackson’s 1992 rapes of the mother and daughter are remarkably similar to the details in the attack in the Moses-EL case.
“It is long past the time for the truth to come out,” Gail Johnson, one of Moses-EL’s lawyers, wrote in a court filing.
Since being made aware in December 2013 of Jackson’s confession, Morrissey’s office has refused to reopen the case. During that time, Moses-EL’s mother, Eloise Moses, died without having seen her eldest son walk free.
For the past several months, Morrissey’s office has tried to quash new evidence from coming forward in Moses-EL’s post-conviction appeal proceedings. It has said testimony about blood evidence from the scene more likely being Jackson’s than Moses-EL’s isn’t relevant. And Morrissey’s chief deputy, Bonnie Benedetti, has argued that expert testimony debunking the credibility of the victim’s dream identification — as well as other witnesses’ testimonies — would be a waste of the court’s time.
Most notably, Benedetti has tried to silence Jackson from testifying today by urging him to lawyer-up and take the Fifth to avoid prosecution, even though he’s already serving more than a life sentence and Benedetti has said in court that the statute of limitations already has tolled. Benedetti has said that in an interview with her, Jackson recanted his confession.
Morrissey, it seems, is unwilling to acknowledge not only that his office may have wrongly prosecuted Moses-EL, but also that Morrissey himself has for nine years willfully refused to reopen Moses-EL’s case since it became clear Jackson’s pattern of violent rape warrants a new investigation.
“Out of an abundance of caution,” his office told The Independent Tuesday, it’s refusing comment.
“This Mitch Morrissey is doing everything he can to cover his behind and hide the truth in this case,” said David Reese, 47, who has flown from Baltimore for today’s hearing in support of the brother who was ripped from his family half a lifetime ago.
“What is it about Denver – convicting a man on nothing but a dream? A dream? Really?
“What’s happened here is a nightmare. It’s a nightmare this man Morrissey and this city need to own up to.”
Top Photo: Moses EL, photo by Susan Greene
Like this story? Steal it! Feel free to republish it in part or in full, just please give credit to The Colorado Independent and add a link to the original.
SIGN UP FOR OUR WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
The Colorado Criminal Defense Bar (CCDB) and the Community College of Denver (CCD) Paralegal Program are holding a public debate for the candidates seeking the position […]Read More
The Home Front: In immigration meeting with Trump, Colorado sheriff asks for federal funds to ‘indemnify sheriffs when sued by the ACLU’
“Larimer County Sheriff Justin Smith was among a small group of law enforcement officials invited to the White House on Tuesday to speak about immigration […]Read More