Awaiting the healthcare vote in a town Obamacare didn’t help

Awaiting the healthcare vote in a town Obamacare didn’t help

HUGO, Colo. — From the bed in his bright, airy room at Lincoln Community Hospital, a nonprofit 15-bed facility on the western edge of this 800-person town, Ted Lyons rifles through a U.S. Post Office box stuffed with medical bills.

His hands, trembling with Parkinson’s, find the one he’s looking for. It shows that Lyons owes $12,000 for 30 days’ worth of care for a serious skin infection he has been battling for months. To cover this one, he says, he has made a deal with the hospital to take out a deed on some storage units he co-owns. Another bill shows that he must pay $1,400 for a single medication prescription. The box holds more than a dozen other folded documents on identical letterhead.

At 68, Lyons is on Medicare, which saw no change under the Affordable Care Act and is not expected to see change under the American Health Care Act, now being pushed by Republicans in Congress. (Republican leaders in the House postponed today’s vote in the struggle to round up enough votes for passage.)

But Lyons says that the costs of his medications are still unmanageable under Medicare’s drug benefit, and those costs illustrate the larger point about the healthcare debate in the U.S. “It’ll just eat you alive,” he says of the financial burden, speaking with labored breaths. He fears that even with supplemental insurance coverage, this one illness is going to drain his life’s savings.

His experience with Medicare after more than 30 years with “very good” private insurance coverage has piqued Lyons’ interest in the failings of the U.S. healthcare system.

“There’s got to be a solution to it,” he says. “I don’t have all the answers, but what’s been going on isn’t working. We’ve tried it for seven or eight years.” This frustration is partly what motivated Lyons, like 78 percent of the residents in Lincoln County, to vote for President Donald Trump.

Ted Lyons grants an interview from his hospital bed in Lincoln Community Hospital. (Photo by Allen Tian)

Ted Lyons grants an interview from his hospital bed in Lincoln Community Hospital. (Photo by Allen Tian)

It’s not just Lyons who is suffering. Lincoln Community Hospital, like many rural hospitals across the U.S., is struggling financially. Many of these rural hospitals, even those in deeply red counties, fear what passage of the Republican-backed American Health Care Act would mean for health insurance coverage, and thus for their bottom lines.

Lincoln Community Hospital is the only hospital for a radius of about 70 miles, and it offers not only walk-in and emergency room care but provides ambulatory services, long-term care and 17 total specialties. Without it, patients would have to travel long distances to receive treatment.

But Lincoln’s situation is a bit unique. Unlike the majority of rural hospitals, which saw significant financial benefits from Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act, Lincoln has seen its revenues dwindle in recent years. In 2012, it ended the year $1.7 million in the black. In 2015, the nonprofit netted barely $150,000.

“It’s a bit of an anomaly,” admits Joe Hanel, who manages public policy outreach for the Colorado Health Institute. “This is just not a county that benefitted a whole lot from the ACA.” Hanel says that in a dataset of 86 Colorado hospitals, only 10 saw revenues decrease over the past few years. The Colorado Hospital Association lists 41 rural hospitals in the state.

Lincoln’s status as something of an outlier helps explain why on Wednesday, on the eve of the expected push by Republicans in the U.S. House of Representatives to repeal the ACA, you don’t find in Hugo the same post-Trump regrets reportedly found in other rural, pro-Trump communities — the fear that any rollback of the ACA’s Medicaid expansion could be the last straw.

That’s not to say the hospital’s employees aren’t worried about healthcare under a Republican plan, especially as it has been drafted to this point. But for now, they are more focused on what they see as the most critical issue: Whether Colorado will keep its rural hospitals in mind when it plans for next year’s budget.

The emergency room at Lincoln Community Hospital. (Photo by Allen Tian)

The emergency room at Lincoln Community Hospital. (Photo by Allen Tian)

Since Colorado implemented the Affordable Care Act’s expansion of Medicaid, most rural hospitals have seen their revenues increase. That’s because they now receive federal Medicaid reimbursement for patients who previously would have been uninsured. Hospitals like San Luis Valley Health Medical Center, which serves patients around poor, rural Alamosa County, used this injection of funds under Medicaid expansion to update their equipment, expand their hours and improve their bottom line.

But Lincoln County is different. When conservative residents of Hugo complain that the Affordable Care Act didn’t do much for them, it’s not sour grapes. The numbers tell the same story.

The Affordable Care Act presented two main benefits: An expansion of the qualifications for Medicaid coverage, and federal subsidies for lower-income Americans to buy individual health insurance on the health exchange. Medicaid enrollment here did rise about 7 percent, which parallels the state average. About 24 percent of Lincoln County’s approximately 5,000 residents are now on Medicaid, and a significant percentage of the aging population is on Medicare. But Lincoln’s demographics mean the Affordable Care Act’s benefits mostly end there. Those who don’t qualify for Medicaid earn too much to qualify for the ACA tax credits.

Only 1.2 percent of all Lincoln County residents get subsidies to purchase healthcare on the ACA exchange. Rising premiums and slimmer pickings on the exchange likely pushed those without subsidies to purchase lower quality plans, such as those offering only catastrophic coverage, with higher premiums and higher deductibles, says Lincoln Community Hospital CEO Kevin Stansbury.

That shift, he says, has been noticeable. “If you’re paying $1,000 a month in insurance premiums, more than your house payment, you don’t have the disposable income then to suddenly meet that deductible when you come in needing care. We actually saw an uptick in our bad debt because of that issue.”

Hospitals, particularly those in rural areas, know that some of their patients either won’t be able to pay or will choose not to. Uncompensated care can be classified as “bad debt” or “charity pay.” When insured patients ultimately default on their medical bills, it’s “bad debt.” In 2015, Lincoln Community Hospital’s bad debt costs were nearly $800,000, and the cost has been rising over several years.

“Our sense is, the reason for the increase in bad debt is attributable to the increase in high deductible plans and patients’ inability to fund their deductibles,” says Stansbury. He adds, “We have more people coming in because of Medicaid — that’s better than nothing — but then this other group that we counted on, that commercial insurance group, now suddenly they’re in these exchange plans with very high deductibles. So we sort of swapped that out,” he says. “That’s a problem that we’d like to be solved.”

For Ted Lyons, the medical bills have added up quickly, even with Medicare. (Photo by Allen Tian)

For Ted Lyons, the medical bills have added up quickly, even with Medicare. (Photo by Allen Tian)

Stansbury is hopeful about a few aspects of the proposed AHCA. He hopes that giving a larger role to market forces will bring premiums down, and he likes that the new plan addresses the issue of tort reform. Without this legal reform, doctors often conduct unnecessary tests out of a fear of lawsuits, something he calls “defensive medicine.” He also says that he’s in favor of block grants to states, rather than dollars earmarked for specific purposes, “because it gives us more flexibility.” (Critics say that block grants, which don’t increase with rising Medicaid enrollment, would amount to funding cuts.)

But Stansbury says the bottom line comes down to, well, the bottom line. “Rural healthcare has got to be funded enough. The fear I have is there’s going to be a meat-ax approach to cutting costs, which will lead to a continued gap in life expectancy between rural and urban communities. We’ll see our communities dwindle down.” As of 2009, the life expectancy gap between urban and rural residents was two years and predicted to grow.

Hope comes in the form of the state’s Hospital Provider Fee, which redistributes monies from larger hospitals to those in smaller, poorer areas. The fee is at risk of major cuts under a budget proposal by Gov. John Hickenlooper in an attempt to keep the state from losing revenue under the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights. TABOR, which was approved by voters, limits how much revenue the state can collect before triggering refunds to taxpayers.

Democrats in the statehouse have tried for years to reclassify the fee to, in essence, pull it out from beneath TABOR limits, thus freeing up hundreds of millions of dollars for education, health care and other state needs. Republicans have fought against the reclassification, saying it thwarts the will of the voters to keep state spending down. To the surprise, then, of many State Sen. Jerry Sonnenberg, a key Republican lawmaker whose district includes 11 rural hospitals — including Lincoln — broke ranks and announced Tuesday that he will sponsor a bill to reclassify this fee so that it doesn’t affect TABOR limits. Reclassification, if successful, would likely eliminate the need for a cut, though that’s still in contention.

Stansbury, and several other members of the Lincoln County staff, expressed their wish that Congress would take its time, rather than rushing to push a new plan through in the first 90 days of the Trump administration. “There is not a one size fits all answer to this, even among rural healthcare providers,” he says. Ken Buck, who represents Lincoln County in the House, was still undecided before today’s vote was postponed.

For all his frustration with the realities of the Affordable Care Act, Lyons, too, isn’t exactly thrilled with all of the partisan fighting in Congress.

“I don’t know if they couldn’t have taken some parts of Obamacare and patched the parts that weren’t working if they could have gotten along,” he says.

 

Photos by Allen Tian

Like this story? Steal it! Feel free to republish it in part or in full, just please give credit to The Colorado Independent and add a link to the original.

Got a tip? Story pitch? Send us an e-mail. Follow The Colorado Independent on Twitter.



About the Author

Kelsey Ray

7 Comments

  1. Terry Cannon on said:

    Why is Ted Lyons being billed if he is on Medicare? Is he actually on Medicare Parts A and B, or does he have a Medicare Advantage plan (Medicare Part C, which is actually NOT Medicare?) Does he have Medicare Part D which pays for medications? It does cost the person to have Medicare Part D, but it would be much cheaper than those expensive prescriptions if they’re covered.

    As the article points out, the ACA did not affect Medicare. But I can guarantee Mr Lyons one thing – voting for the GOP will not help him. The GOP wants to end Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security. That has been their aim since the inception of those programs, programs that have kept millions of seniors out of poverty for decades.

  2. Lincoln County Resident on said:

    Have they thought about the fact that the Lincoln Community Hospital just sucks? How many many local residents just avoid it because the quality of healthcare there is lackluster (putting it mildly? How the staff is just overall highly incompetent? How their MRI and other machines are so antiquated that about half of all diagnostic testing there needs to be repeated at a better facility where they have better equipment? How the local veterinary clinics provide better medicine for our animals than they do at the LCH? How maybe the other rural hospitals cited perhaps provide better care? Or even how Ted Lyons keeps getting profiled in these articles because he’s perhaps the only actual overnight patient there?
    I have insurance and pay my bills but I won’t darken the door there unless I’m dying.

  3. Concerned Resident on said:

    The fact that the Lincoln Community Hospital uses most of their funds for ‘renovations’ that are not a necessity cause them to be in the hole! This hospital is one of the worst in the state and it’s standards are subpar! They provide horrible service and expect people to pay for it!

  4. Lincoln county resident on said:

    Wonder if Mr Lyons has a supplemental policy since Medicare has some limits. For a very small amount thru AARP and other you can be 100% covered.As far as the hospital, I wonder if the change in administration, building a new clinic in Limon, purchase of an assisted living facility and now, hiring consulting firm to consider more growth? With declining revenues, it seems like improving existing services would be wise. It is easier to judge from the outside of course!

  5. Kevin Stansbury, MS, JD, FACHE, CEO on said:

    I welcome any of the anonymous commenters to contact me directly. While I disagree strongly with the general criticisms noted, I also believe we improve by listening carefully about our shortcomings. I look forward to the dialogue should you choose to call. Thank you.
    Dear “Lincoln County Resident” – I’m disappointed you chose to express your grievances about the care we provide in an anonymous fashion. Perhaps you missed our recent community meetings where we actively solicit patient feedback in an effort to improve. While I acknowledge that our hospital, like every hospital in the world, has room for improvement, I vehemently resent your characterization that our care “sucks”. Firstly, your description that our staff is highly incompetent is simply incorrect. Our clinical staff members are all highly credentialed in their fields and ensure their competency by continuously training to ensure that their skills are at the highest level. You are also incorrect regarding our MRI and other equipment; to the contrary our MRI was installed less than one year ago, as was our CT. We (and I suggest nor do you) have any evidence that “about half of all diagnostic testing needs to be repeated.” Indeed our imaging is overseen by one of the largest radiology groups in the city, who routinely monitor our quality. I assure you our quality ranks very high amongst all the hospitals they work with which, includes big Denver health systems. We hope that you are never in emergent need of our services, as you stated “dying”, however in the case that you are, we will be here; regardless of your ability to pay. If that unfortunate circumstance should come to pass, perhaps you can join the many neighbors and visitors who write me and our board on a regular basis thanking us for the competent compassionate care. Often those letters end with “you saved my life.” We’ll be here for you.
    As noted above, we relish opportunities for growth and improvement and invite you to discuss your concerns directly and openly. I encourage you to contact me directly so that we might continue this discussion in a more constructive manner. I am proud of the care we provide, the staff that work here and believe the care we provide at our hospital and clinics is comparable to any other hospitals in the state. I look forward to further dialogue, but let’s have the discussion face to face. Thank you.
    Neighbors Caring for Neighbors
    Kevin M. Stansbury, MS, JD, FACHE
    Chief Executive Officer
    719.743.2421 ext 3230
    Lincoln Community Hospital
    111 6th St.
    Hugo, Colorado 80821
    kstansbury@lchnh.com

  6. Kevin Stansbury, MS, JD, FACHE, CEO on said:

    I welcome any of the anonymous commenters to contact me directly. While I disagree strongly with the general criticisms noted, I also believe we improve by listening carefully about our shortcomings. I look forward to the dialogue should you choose to call. Thank You.
    Neighbors Caring for Neighbors
    Kevin M. Stansbury, MS, JD, FACHE
    Chief Executive Officer
    719.743.2421 ext 3230
    Lincoln Community Hospital
    111 6th St.
    Hugo, Colorado 80821
    kstansbury@lchnh.com

  7. Lincoln County Resident on said:

    (I am the Lincoln County Resident with capital letters.)

    We’ve lived here quite a long time so some of the incidents I’m recalling are before your tenure as CEO.

    Once shame on you, twice shame on me, as the saying goes.

    Some of my fellow Lincoln County Residents and I have swapped horror stories. I am not isolated in receiving poor care from the LCH.

    I may call you- let me think about this. I don’t pretend to know what goes into running a rural hospital or any hospital at all.

Leave a Response

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>