‘Black Sunday’ lessons from 30 years ago coloring Colorado oil shale debate today

Thirty years ago, Herb Bacon was working in the old U.S. Bank of Grand Junction when a man operating Exxon’s local oil shale project walked into the lobby with his usual pep in his step.

“He stopped in almost every week and when he came in one particular Friday, I asked him how things were going and he said they’d never been better,” Bacon, 82, recalled last night. “He was expecting a group from Japan to take a tour that weekend. The following Sunday I was out in front of my house trimming the hedge — I had attended church earlier that morning — when my wife came out and said, ‘You won’t believe what I just heard on the news: Exxon is shutting down its operation here.’”

That day on May 2, 1982, became known as “Black Sunday,” when Exxon laid off 2,200 oil shale workers on Colorado’s Western Slope. The Colony Project, as it was called, had such a profound impact on the region that when Exxon walked away, small businesses in the area quickly mothballed, entire towns emptied out, there was a run on a local bank, and a bank president committed suicide.

“The best business to be in at the time would have been the moving business,” said Bacon, noting that thousands of residents fled the Grand Valley, which without warning was left in dire straits.

“It was total chaos. There was a big boom and an even bigger bust,” said Andrew Gulliford, a history professor at Fort Lewis College in Durango who authored Boomtown Blues: Colorado Oil Shale. “For many people, it’s a sobering event they look back on much like John F. Kennedy’s assassination — what were they doing? – but unlike with JFK’s assassination, they had to put their lives back together.”

It took a decade before the region bounced back. Now the Grand Valley’s economy is far more diversified. The outdoor recreation industry, organic farmers and vintners all depend on its environs.

Some of the locals who stuck around slapped “Exxon Sucks Rocks” bumper stickers on their cars and trucks, referring to the technology that heats shale rock and sand to extract organic kerogen, or fossilized algae, and refine it into synthetic fuel. Despite trying for nearly a century, engineers have so far been unable to make oil shale — not to be confused with shale oil — commercially viable.

Chevron is the latest to abandon oil shale in Colorado. The company was one of just three to hold oil shale leases in the state. Royal Dutch Shell and AMSO are the other two. Chevron, which began amassing acreage in Colorado for oil shale research back in the 1930s, decided it had other priorities.

An in-situ oil shale research project in Colorado. (USGS photo).
Even so, enthusiasm for oil shale has been flowing through the chambers of Congress where men like U.S. Rep. Doug Lamborn, R-Colo., are vigorously trying to open more public land to oil shale drilling despite objections from conservationists and studies that warn about diminishing water supplies.

The resource’s potential keeps companies coming back too. Earlier this year Shell said it produced 1,700 barrels of oil from an oil shale project on private land in western Colorado and it recently broke ground on its first project on Bureau of Land Management property. A company executive recently declared that Shell, which began researching oil shale in 1981, is making “significant progress.”

Those who have seen this play out before are urging decision-makers to proceed with caution.

“I don’t think anybody knows exactly how this is going to end,” Bacon said. “If it really works out, it would be a tremendous boon, but we thought that was going to happen in the 1980s and it didn’t. Oil shale was going to be a big thing in the 1920s. Several times they got excited and it just didn’t gel.”

A new report, Oil Shale: A Century of Failure, from the Checks and Balances Project (pdf) details the devastation oil shale has had on communities. The Checks and Balances report comes as the BLM is closing its public comment period on its new oil-shale development plan (pdf).

1 COMMENT

  1. […] Yep, while the rest of the world is weaning themselves off of dependency upon oil, its price, boom/bust and other volatility, we've got the people that supported tax cuts as a means to pay for two wars they also supported going full steam ahead on a plan to help private Canadian business gets it's oil to a port it can then ship it to the highest bidders (not Americans). Another pipeline: "Future of the pipeline." "Decline in oil production has posed a serious problem for the pipeline." "By 2015, it is anticipated that daily oil throughput will approach 500,000 barrels per day (79,000 m3/d), unless additional sources of oil are developed.[177] As volumes decrease, Alyeska will begin closing pump stations. The company intends to close all but four stations, because the lower throughput will require less pumping to maintain its momentum.[131] While some reports supporting drilling in the ANWR coastal plain maintain that the pipeline may reach its minimum operating level of 200,000 barrels per day (32,000 m3/d) by 2020[178] the Trans-Alaska Pipeline System Renewal Environmental Impact Statement estimated levels above this through at least 2032[179] due to ongoing exploration outside ANWR. Improvements that allow low flow-rates could extend its lifespan as far as 2075."[134] "By law, Alyeska is required to remove all traces of the pipeline after oil extraction is complete. No date has been set for this removal, but plans for it are being updated continuously."[180] Trans-Alaska Pipeline System – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Posted this several times in the past: Oil shale economics – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia This, as with mention of previous oil boom busts, will mean nothing to people who are only interested in political defiance, not moving into the modern world in this case, the 21st century. Falling Oil Price ?Changing Whole Dynamic? for Tar Sands – Oil Change InternationalOil Change International This I also posted a number of times in the past, long before oil prices dropped. Colony Shale Oil Project – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia ?Black Sunday? lessons from 30 years ago coloring Colorado oil shale debate today | The Colorado Ind… […]

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.