Littwin: Cory Gardner picks the exact right time to go rogue on Trump’s shutdown

Sen. Cory Gardner speaks to a Chamber of Commerce group at the Arizona Biltmore in Phoenix in May 2018. (Photo by Greg Skidmore, via Flickr:Creative Commons)
Sen. Cory Gardner speaks to a Chamber of Commerce group at the Arizona Biltmore in Phoenix in May 2018. (Photo by Greg Skidmore, via Flickr:Creative Commons)

Give Cory Gardner credit. Not only did he go rogue — shocking in its own right — he went rogue at just the right moment.

I mean, Gardner couldn’t have had any idea that just one day after becoming the first Senate Republican to say publicly that the shutdown must end with or without Donald Trump’s wall, Trump would tell Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer in a White House meeting that if he doesn’t get his wall, the shutdown could last “months or even years.”

He certainly had no idea that Trump would hold a Rose Garden press-conference ramblethon during which he would say, almost in passing, he was considering declaring a national emergency to build the wall without congressional approval. For those who worry about democracy dying under Trump, this won’t help you sleep tonight. Neither will learning the powers that any president can actually summon in an emergency.

This emergency would presumably be about all those terrorists/Middle Easterners Trump likes to cite crossing at the border. And yet the State Department’s Bureau of Counterterrorism wrote in July of 2017 — during Trump’s tenure — that it had no information of  “any member of a terrorist group” crossing the border with Mexico.

Maybe Gardner could have guessed — but only because it’s Trump, who is rarely constrained by the facts — that Trump would make the case that many of the 800,000 federal workers going without pay were more than happy to do so if it meant helping Trump resolve what he calls the crisis on the southern border. Meanwhile CNN reports that hundreds of unpaid TSA airport screeners called in sick Friday.

And, of course, there was this for the fact-checkers: Trump’s claim that some former presidents had told him they wished they had built a wall. Here are the former presidents during Trump’s tenure: Obama, Bush 43, Clinton, Bush 41 (before his recent death), Carter. You see any pro-wall guys there? I know Carter builds houses, but I’m pretty sure that’s where he stops on walls.

I could go on, but what’s the point? Oh, yeah, if the shutdown goes much longer, your tax refund could be delayed. But I’m guessing if you don’t get the refund by May or June, Mexico will pay it. Maybe Mexico will send up groceries, too, for those who may affected by reductions in food stamps.

Did anyone bother to think of these ramifications? Apparently not. The truth is, there is a national emergency. It’s called Trump. The question is, what will Senate Republicans do about it? Susan Collins sort of followed in Gardner’s footsteps, also calling for ending the shutdown, but not nearly as starkly as Gardner did. And Gardner made his case while Mitch McConnell, whom Gardner tends to meekly follow, has very publicly refused to play any kind of role in resolving the shutdown.

If you want to see Gardner on the point, Kyle Clarke had the interview on 9News. Gardner seemed a little, well, nervous. You can’t blame him. He has spent two years getting back into Trump’s favor after calling him a buffoon during the campaign. I mean, this interview may have seen Gardner’s lowest smile count in memory. For days, Gardner had been dodging reporters who wanted to ask him about the shutdown, but when he finally made his statement, he then had no choice but to explain it.

And that’s where it got weird. Gardner, ever the good soldier, not only bucked Trump, he also praised Nancy Pelosi, who has replaced Hillary Clinton as the GOP’s favorite bogeywoman, although Elizabeth Warren and Breakfast-Club-dancing Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez are also in the running. Gardner’s praise for Pelosi — he twice cited her House package on re-opening the government — is so far removed from the Republican playbook that he might as well have been quoting from Noam Chomsky.

Not that Gardner has much choice here. If he wants to be re-elected in 2020 in a state in which voters have profoundly rejected Trump at every opportunity, he has to put some distance between himself and the president. No wonder he’s nervous. I mean, there’s no guarantee it would work. Ask the formerly invincible Mike Coffman, who went far more rogue than Gardner will ever do, and still got clobbered by a political neophyte.

How far is Gardner willing to go? He’s got a test right now. Will he say anything about Trump’s national-emergency threat? His lack of concern for government workers missing paychecks? His stated willingness to let a shutdown go on for years? If Gardner wants to distance himself from Trump, that’s where he has to go — someplace really rogue.

Meanwhile, Gardner’s pal Pelosi introduced an anti-corruption, voter-reform bill on the second day of her historic second tour as House speaker. The Senate will never hear this bill — just as McConnell has promised never to allow the Senate to vote on the House-passed end-the-shutdown bill. But these are the kinds of battles that will be fought between the Republican Senate and Democratic House, where Pelosi, when she’s not meeting with Trump, is busily tamping down, uh, colorful talk from Dem newcomers about impeachment.

I’m pretty sure impeachment is hardly Trump’s biggest problem now. I don’t think Bob Mueller’s Russia probe is Trump’s biggest problem now either. If Trump is truly willing to allow a shutdown that lasts for months, he is actively daring anxious Republicans to join the resistance. What I mean is, once you lose Cory Gardner, even if just on one issue, you’re in danger of losing anyone.


  1. Whatever bill Mitch McConnell chooses to allow on the Senate floor to resolve the Trump Shutdown will need only 10 Republican votes. So Mitch can afford to back-bench Cory on this one to try to save the his Senate seat in 2020. I can’t imagine a scenario where this strategy will spare Gardner from drowning Colorado’s rising blue tide.

  2. It’s so easy for The Smiler to talk big. If Cory doesn’t caucus with the Dems, his words are meaningless and his actions will still be supporting the traitor Donald John Trump.

  3. It is way too late for Corrupt Gardner…he has shown that he cannot be trusted at all…look at all the flip flopping from Legal weed to the wall…the only thing we need to know about gardner, is that he is a right winger who has no qualms about allowing this president to attack our government…He has abandoned his credibility for Koch money…and not to mention the NRA/Russian money he banked…then there are the shady elements of the Cambridge Analytical boast of helping gardner cheat…there are surprising stories behind this guy gardner…who has never held a real job in his life…who has never suffered from lack of money for food, or health care…who would strip SSI, SSDI, Medicare and Medicade for the profits of the Koch boys…Gardner must be voted out…

  4. The Senate can’t do much without Sen. McConnell allowing it. There is no “discharge petition” for legislation EXCEPT for the repeal of regulations.

    So, the question is, what will Cory actually DO? Withhold consent on legislative action? Put holds on nominees (a la Jeff Flake in the waning weeks of the previous Session)? What’s HIS strategy for the shutdown?

  5. Give Cory the credit he’s due for speaking up about trump’s shutdown (It’s especially difficult when your “leader” – McConnell – is like the walking dead. and has turned over the Senate’s authority to trump.), but note he very clearly has stated he supports “the wall” and trump’s 5.6 billion dollar request.

    Cory needs some accurate facts about the effectiveness of trump’s proposed wall and the actual issues around immigration. Since he’s not going to hear them from this group of Repubs, we need to keep attempting to educate him.

  6. Smiling Cory just wants to survive so he can gut Social Security and Medicare.
    He is a Koch sucker and they hate taxes–especially to help people.

  7. If you believe this is anything other than a pathetic ploy to help Cory Gardner hold onto his job, then you haven’t been keeping tabs on Cory Gardner. He has to run to the middle now and pretend he’s not a Trump/McConnell toady since 2020 is coming soon. I can’t wait to see him gone…

  8. His Coloradan Constituents stood outside his office everyday for the last three years and he never spoke to us ONCE. He denied the press the opportunity to interview him and even had the Denver police brutalize severely disabled protestors who were only asking him to LISTEN to how desperately they need their healthcare and civil rights. He happily voted to raise all of our taxes and give the top 1% the biggest tax break in history ,leaving the trillion dollar debt to our children. He was happy vote to take away our healthcare. He happily voted for justices who were sexual predators and who want to control women’s reproductive health. He happily voted to deregulate environmental rules that protect our water, food and air. This final showy stand to keep our government open doesn’t forgive him for not standing up to the evils in the Senate that have sold our Democracy for a lousy BUCK.

  9. As a Colorado voter, I can safely say Gardner’s political career, as lack-luster and ineffectual as it has been, is clearly over. The Koch brothers bought him at a step discount of only $125,000. Even at that low, low price for a senator, I’m sure they are deeply disappointed. Little Corey Gardner should move to Kansas where his failed CONservative and librarian ideologies are still blindly accepted.

  10. Though I occasionally vote Republican, I will never, ever vote for Cory Gardner; He’s totally tied to Trump and McConnell. Hopefully, no Democrat or Independent who follows the news (other than on Trump’s Fox stations) believes a word out of his mouth; it’s finally occurred to Gardner that 2020 will be his political demise…

Comments are closed.