Denver Sheriff Patrick Firman expected to resign or be fired

"He believes things are going great, but they’re crumbling around him," one department veteran said.

Denver's downtown jail, overseen by the Sheriff's Department, has been the subject of consistent controversy for years. Sheriff Patrick Firman was hired as a "change agent" for the department, but the mayor — and many others — have been disappointed in his performance. (Photo by Alex Burness)

Denver Sheriff Patrick Firman has lost the confidence of city leaders and his own employees, and his departure from the position is imminent.

A half-dozen people who either work for or with Firman describe him as absent, in over his head and ill-equipped to either improve his department’s performance or rehabilitate its severely wounded image.

Sources said he’ll either resign or be fired soon.

These sources spoke to The Colorado Independent on condition of anonymity, saying they were not authorized to speak about Firman’s status.

Firman did not respond to an interview request. His boss, Director of Safety Troy Riggs, declined to comment. Mayor Michael Hancock also declined to be interviewed about the sheriff he appointed in 2015 to be a “change agent.” 

Patrick Firman was appointed by Mayor Michael Hancock to be a “change agent.” But the troubled Sheriff’s Department has been slow to reform, and its leader is expected to either resign or be fired soon. (Photo courtesy City of Denver)

“We are not going to comment on unconfirmed rumors from unnamed sources regarding city personnel,” said his spokeswoman, Theresa Marchetta.

The 1,100-employee Sheriff Department oversees Denver’s two jails and protects city and county courtrooms and courthouses. It also carries out evictions.

Denver is one of just two Colorado counties without an elected sheriff.

Firman, previously a career corrections official in Illinois, started in Denver in the wake of several highly publicized excessive force cases, including sheriff’s deputies killing of a homeless black man named Marvin Booker at the downtown jail. A month into Firman’s tenure, deputies killed another homeless black man, Michael Marshall, also at the jail. 

The Booker and Marshall cases resulted in $6 million jury award and civil settlement, respectively. Other civil rights cases filed on behalf of prisoners who were killed or injured at the jails cost city taxpayers many millions more.

The city has spent about $31 million on reform efforts since 2015, and last summer touted its progress in a report titled “Beyond Reform.”

“As a community, the Sheriff Department and the residents of this city embarked on significant reformation that has set this department on a transformational path, and I am proud of the progress we have made together,” Hancock said when the report came out.

Behind the scenes, Hancock has been displeased with Firman and his ability to enact meaningful reform, sources said.

Firman has also been unable to build public trust since his tumultuous beginning, and, increasingly, his own employees are speaking out about their own lack of trust in him and in the department’s direction.

“I haven’t met or talked to anybody in our department that thinks he’s doing a spectacular job. It’s the opposite: that he’s ineffective,” said a sheriff’s captain with more than 20 years in the department. “Everybody feels this way.”

“Morale is in the gutter,” said another 20-plus-year department veteran, adding, of the staff perception of Firman: “What’s the word I’m looking for? Absent. That’s one word. Totally oblivious. Has no pulse of what’s going on. He believes things are going great, but they’re crumbling around him.”

Firman has become notorious among the ranks for how little time he spends in the jails and for avoiding staffers and prisoners.

His nickname is ‘the sasquatch,” one employee said. “He doesn’t come around, he doesn’t show his face. The only time is when there’s a major incident.” 

From the start, Firman’s public appearances have been few and far between compared to Safety Director Riggs and Police Chief Paul Pazen and their predecessors, Stephanie O’Malley and Robert White. Firman occasionally attends press conferences, but rarely has given interviews.

Meanwhile, the department he oversees has been embroiled in regular controversy since before he arrived and during his tenure. In addition to the Booker and Marshall killings, violence has persisted.

A 2017 survey showed that despite the millions spent on reform efforts, deputies overwhelmingly felt problems remained unchanged under Firman’s watch and that the department lacks leadership, trains them inadequately, and keeps its jails dangerously overcrowded. 

The month after Firman started, more than a dozen jail deputies filed a federal lawsuit claiming that department leaders hadn’t protected women employees from “vile, damaging and degrading” remarks and behavior from male inmates.

“When supervising and guarding male prisoners” — 30-60 at a time, their lawsuit read — “a female deputy is often assigned as the lone deputy in a pod where she is surrounded and outnumbered (by) male prisoners. Sexual remarks are often tinged with threats of violence.” 

The suit also asserted that the women are physically isolated from their male colleagues and, as a result of that and other factors, are subjected to “increased levels of job stress, job burnout and emotional harm when compared to male deputies.”

Sources said a settlement in that case could go before the City Council in a matter of days or weeks, and that the total could approach or exceed $1 million. (Update: The council approved the settlement on Monday, Sept. 9, in the total amount of $1.55 million.)

Two former jail deputies told The Independent in May that their bosses in the Sheriff Department denied them bathroom breaks during work shifts and that they were forced to urinate in plastic bags and on the floor.

On Wednesday, Mike Britton, vice president of the sheriff’s union local and a frequent critic of Firman, said the problem persists.

We have female officers that are not getting relieved off their post” to breastfeed, he said. “We had one officer who lactated all the way through her uniform.”

Sources said Riggs and Mayor Hancock have long been displeased with Firman’s performance, but that no party was keen to shake up the Sheriff Department ahead of Hancock’s June re-election. 

With the election over but the concerns about Firman unchanged — intensified, if anything, among the rank-and-file — city leadership is now bracing for his resignation, sources said, adding that Firman has looked at potential new work opportunities back in Illinois.

City leaders are already planning for a resignation or ouster, and have identified several city employees who could step into the role should Firman depart as expected.

That’s not the only sheriff’s personnel problem for Hancock and Riggs.

“What I just heard is that we’re 110 deputies short. We’re supposed to have about 800,” a longtime captain said. “They are leaving faster than we are hiring them. It’s across the board, different reasons why they’re leaving. Retirements, people who don’t want to be here, people who don’t have any trust in the upper administration. There’s a lot of reasons.”

Critics slammed Hancock in 2015 for hiring Firman without a public vetting process. The administration is likely to face further criticism if it appoints his replacement without soliciting pubic input. 

It’s unclear whether Firman’s performance will inspire critics of the city’s appointed-sheriff system to float a referendum seeking to change Denver’s charter to elect rather than appoint the next sheriff.

1 COMMENT

  1. This article and the informants opinions are not those of many of the Denver Deputy Sheriffs. This propaganda has been spread by the FOP Lodge 27 since Mr. Firman was appointed to Sheriff. This was a step in the right direction as was the replacement of Ms. O’Malley which was long overdue. FOP Lodge 27 has not liked Mr. Firman because he came from the outside so they didn’t have a cozy relationship with him as they did his predecessors and the FOP was excluded from the selection process. The FOP Lodge 27 supported Mr. Wilson and Mr. Diggins as they have had a very cozy relationship over the decades which included taking care of each others backs. Should the rumors be true, a new Sheriff still needs to come from the outside as there are too many private agendas and relationships here. FOP Lodge 27 supported Ms. Calderon because if she would have won Mr. Gale would have been appointed as Sheriff but just look at the mess he’s in with the Grand Jury Indictment for a felony crime yet the FOP is paying his legal expenses for his personal actions. At the end of the day many of the examples attributed to Mr. Firman were already in the works as the ground work was laid prior to his appointment. The FOP also wants to blame Sheriff Firman for overcrowding at the Denver Jails but the Denver Sheriff Department doesn’t control who comes to jail but that message doesn’t doesn’t suit their agenda. In our past we have been more severely overcrowd then we are today. In fact our old City Jail which was designed for around 150-160 inmate would routinely see counts in the 300’s which meant that we were triple bunking inmates. At the old County Jail we had cots on a regular basis in our open dorms. We are short staffed because our leaders prior to Sheriff Firman failed to properly staff us even though they were shown how bad this was going to get back in 2012-2013. Not everything that Sheriff Firman has done has been easy to accept or has been done above board but he was brought in as a change agent and that he has done. The FOP just hopes that they can get one of theirs appointed as Sheriff so they can benefit from that relationship.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.