A note about Thursday’s DACA story

Standing aside to let people speak for themselves

Immigrant youth and their supporters rallied outside the Supreme Court of the United States on Nov. 12, 2019. Supreme Court Justices heard arguments on the legality of the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which allows for temporary protection from deportation and permission to work and study in the U.S. for qualified young people. (Photo by Robin Bravender/States Newsroom)
Immigrant youth and their supporters rallied outside the Supreme Court of the United States on Nov. 12, 2019. The court heard arguments on the legality of the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which allows for temporary protection from deportation and permission to work and study in the U.S. for qualified young people. (Photo by Robin Bravender/States Newsroom)

Dear reader,

Over the past couple of weeks, I’ve been interviewing Colorado DACA recipients about their states of mind as they waited for the U.S. Supreme Court to rule on the program’s future. That ruling came this morning and, to the surprise of many, Chief Justice John Roberts sided with the more liberal wing of the bench and against the Trump administration, which sought to scrap DACA.

It was a huge relief for recipients, but it does not end the uncertainty around their futures. After long conversations with five Dreamers, I was planning to weave everything together in a single article, sprinkling in quotes from all of them.

But like many of you, I have been thinking about my role in a society where we do not listen to people directly affected by the policies we sanction. I’ve been thinking about all the protesters demanding equity. I’ve been thinking about how my job as a journalist is not just to bear witness and demand accountability, but also to stand aside when it is time to stand aside and let people speak for themselves in stories that are about them.

By definition of my job as a reporter, I am a gatekeeper. I decide how a story is framed. I decide whose voices to include. Someone once told me, or maybe I read it somewhere, that we must do what the story demands. This story demanded that these Dreamers talk to you directly. I edited my transcription of our conversations, ordering paragraphs to give the individual stories a logical arc because each conversation ran thousands of words. But these are their words. These are their experiences. Each is powerful in its own way. I hope you will take the time to listen to Kenia, Rene, Abner, Armando and Mario.

When I fact-checked with each of them, several choked up. Abner began to cry. He had not, he said, ever been able to tell his full story and he had never heard his own words read back to him. That’s what I mean by standing aside. Nothing, I assure you, nothing I could have written is a substitute for their own words in the wake of today’s ruling.

You may notice that my byline on this piece reads “Colorado News Collaborative” rather than “The Colorado Independent.” Our transition to our new nonprofit home is underway and that byline is not just a byline. It is a pledge to work with newsrooms around the state to do what we can to strengthen journalism. That will look different on a story-by-story basis, but for this one, it was the reason I sought out Dreamers in Fort Collins, Olathe, Grand Junction, Pueblo and Carbondale. Those communities are all served by local newsrooms scrambling to keep their audiences informed, and these young people are their people, too. Any  local newsroom can publish, if it so chooses, this or any of our COLab stories for its readers and then be freed up to do other reporting on other stories of local importance. It’s a win-win and, in a time when newsrooms throughout the state are pressed for resources, one of the ways we at COLab are here to help.

Thank you, as always, for being the readers you are — inquisitive, demanding, voracious, generous. And to steal the motto of our partners at the Colorado Media Project, thank you for understanding that local news is a public good.

Now, time to read those first-persons.

Tina

This note went to our readers earlier today. Want to stay in the loop on our transition and other journalism goodness? Please sign up here

Tina is an editor, reporter and coach with the Colorado News Collaborative, a new nonprofit partnership between The Colorado Press Association, The Colorado Media Project and The Colorado Independent, where she was the managing editor. In a previous life, Tina was a city columnist for the late great Rocky Mountain News and the Denver Post. Tina lives in Fort Collins with her husband and two kids. She's a native New Mexican and prefers red over green.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.